Home Asia The Best Scholarly Books of the Decade
The Best Scholarly Books of the Decade
By Raj At April 19, 2020 0
Last year, in a pungent essay for Harper’s, Christian Lorentzen railed against the media’s obsession for bookish "Best Of" lists, which have in recent years “achieved a sort of mania": "What is the utility — to anyone — of an item like ‘Hot Books for Cold Days’?" He has a point. At their worst, such lists are little better than advertising puffery.
This list is better — more like a conversation among friends than a boosterish emanation of the publishing industry. As every scholar knows, it can become all too easy to cease learning about ideas outside of one’s own field. If you’re craving recommendations for recent reading across disciplines, these essays — for which we’ve asked 11 scholars to discuss "the best scholarly book" of the last decade — are for you.
Is this list definitive? Of course not. But it is rich, surprising, and idiosyncratic. You're probably stuck at home. Here's what to read next.
It’s been a bad decade for politics, but a great decade for political theory. Three standouts for me were Shatema Threadcraft’s Intimate Justice, Adom Getachew’s Worldmaking After Empire, and Kathi Weeks’s The Problem With Work. But the scholarly book that affected me most powerfully this past decade was Juno Mac and Molly Smith’s Revolting Prostitutes (Verso, 2018). It is a thrilling and formidable intervention into contemporary discussions of sex work, and settles the debate in favor of full and immediate global decriminalization. It does so without insisting that there is nothing troubling about sex work: about the psychosexual forces that lead men to buy it, or the economic forces that compel women to sell it.
To say that "sex work is work" is not to say, Mac and Smith explain, that it is thereby valuable or unproblematic, but simply that it is something that is overwhelmingly done out of material necessity. Mac and Smith show empirically that the women who need to sell sex to survive are rarely made better off through legal restrictions on the selling or purchase of sex. What does make such women better off is the strengthening of their labor power: recourse to legal remedies against violent or non-paying clients, the ability to unionize and form cooperatives, freedom from the carceral power of the state.
Indeed, full decriminalization is the only plausible path to the abolition of sex work. Longstanding feminist pro-criminalization arguments rest, Mac and Smith argue, on the false premise that legal restrictions on sex work decrease its prevalence. In fact, legal restrictions merely drive sex work underground, asymmetrically burdening the more vulnerable party in the exchange: the sellers of sex. This is true, Mac and Smith explain, even of the Nordic model, which criminalizes the purchase but not the sale of sex. (In that model sex workers take more risks to earn the same amount of money, as johns become fearful of arrest.)
Some feminists will remain unconvinced. "For feminist women," they write, "the figure of the prostitute often comes to represent the trauma that is inflicted on all women within patriarchy … The client thus becomes the symbol of all violent men." Mac and Smith sympathize, but urge feminists to resist this impulse. What is really at stake in feminist debates about sex work is a choice between symbolically punishing men on the one hand, and practically improving the conditions of the worst-off women on the other. This is not only a profound diagnosis of the sex-work debate, but also an object lesson in what it looks like to engage sympathetically with one’s opponents — a practice that is too often ceded by radical theorists to liberals and centrists.
Revolting Prostitutes is a model of how to write about politics — or, indeed, anything. That it is written by two sex workers will, but shouldn’t, come as a surprise to many.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments
(
Atom
)


Post a Comment